Skip to content
Sugar Paper
  • Log in
Bag (0)
Subtotal:
Proceed to checkout View cart
  • Bestsellers

    Mindful Journal

    The Baby Book

    • Bestsellers
      • Baby Book
      • Mindful Journal
      • Journals
      • Recipe Book
      • List Pads
      • Notebooks
      • Candles
      • Personalized Gifts
  • Planners

    2022 Planners

    Coming In September

    Calendars

    • Planners
      • 2022 Planners
      • Academic Planners
      • Calendars
  • Desk

    Sugar Paper x Target

    Journals

    • Desk
      • Journals
      • Mindful Journal
      • Address Book
      • Family Planning Pad
      • List Pads
      • Notebooks
      • Pens
      • Sugar Paper Essentials™
      • The Guest Book
  • Stationery

    Custom Stationery

    Boxed Note Sets

    • Stationery
      • Custom Stationery
      • Boxed Note Sets
      • Custom Correspondence
      • Custom Invitations + Announcements
  • Greeting Cards

    Mother's Day Cards

    Birthday Cards

    • Occasions
      • Bestsellers
      • Birthday
      • Mother's Day
      • Father's Day
      • Graduation
      • Thank You
      • Love
      • Friendship
      • Baby
      • Congratulations
      • Wedding + Anniversary
      • Sympathy
      • Card Subscriptions
  • Gifts

    Key Fobs

    personalization

    • Gifts + Gifting
      • Gifts Under $50
      • Gifts Under $100
      • Custom Stationery
      • Personalized Gifts
      • Fabric Pouches
      • Candles
      • Key Fobs
      • Face Masks
      • Gift Tags
      • Gift Cards
  • Bestsellers
    • Back
    • Baby Book
    • Mindful Journal
    • Journals
    • Recipe Book
    • List Pads
    • Notebooks
    • Candles
    • Personalized Gifts
  • Planners
    • Back
    • 2022 Planners
    • Academic Planners
    • Calendars
  • Desk
    • Back
    • Journals
    • Mindful Journal
    • Address Book
    • Family Planning Pad
    • List Pads
    • Notebooks
    • Pens
    • Sugar Paper Essentials™
    • Guest Book
  • Stationery
    • Back
    • Custom Stationery
    • Boxed Note Sets
    • Custom Correspondence
    • Invitations + Announcements
  • Greeting Cards
    • Back
    • Bestsellers
    • Birthday
    • Mother's Day
    • Father's Day
    • Graduation
    • Thank You
    • Love
    • Friendship
    • Baby
    • Congratulations
    • Wedding + Anniversary
    • Sympathy
    • Card Subscriptions
  • Gifts
    • Back
    • Gifts Under $50
    • Gifts Under $100
    • Custom Stationery
    • Personalized Gifts
    • Fabric Pouches
    • Candles
    • Key Fobs
    • Face Masks
    • Gift Tags
    • Gift Cards
  • Login
  • Bag (0)
Home • Bestselling Cards

Bestselling Cards

Our bestselling letterpress cards are printed by hand on extra thick paper.
Cream and black birthday card with black polka dots

Dotty Birthday

$6.00

Blue and white stripe card printed with a gold foil heart

Ticking Stripe Heart

$6.00

White card printed gold foil printed with Miles Apart But Close to the Heart

Miles Apart

$6.00

Black and white letterpress birthday card with girl illustration

Best Of The Best

$6.50

Baby greeting card printed with pink, blue and gold foil with a blue stripe liner

Hello Sweet Baby

$6.50

Chambray paper card printed in gold foil The Best Is Yet To Come

The Best Is Yet To Come

$6.50

The Adventure Continues

The Adventure Continues

$6.00

Kraft and white birthday card with black striped envelope liner

Aged to Perfection

$6.50

Folded white card with XO printed in gold foil

XO Heart

$6.50

White birthday card with pink gold and green ink and a moss green envelope

Truly Amazing Friend, Birthday

$6.00 Sold Out

White, Gold and Pale Blue Birthday Card

Birthday Wishes To You

$6.00

Gold foil printed congratulations card with pink stripe envelope

So Happy For You

$6.00

Hooray Colorful Dot Birthday Card

Hooray! It's Your Birthday

$6.00

White embossed dot card printed with gold foil heartfelt sympathy

Heartfelt Sympathy

$6.50

Blue and white birthday card with gold border and stripe liner

Your Favorite Things

$6.50

White and gold birthday card with neon pink envelope

Someone I Love Was Born Today

$6.00

Pink and gold rainbow friendship card with I can't wait to hug you again

I Can't Wait to Hug You Again

$6.00

White with blue ink birthday card with pink envelope and gold foil dot liner

Traditional Happy Birthday

$6.50

Buffalo Check Thank You Card

Buffalo Check Thank You Card

$6.50

Black, white and gold birthday card with start liner

Growing Up Is Optional

$6.50

Colorful polka dot and gold foil birthday card

Hip Hip Hooray!

$6.00

White card printed with blue ink you've been on my heart with a gold heart lined pink envelope

You've Been On My Heart

$6.50

Neon and pale pink birthday card

Big Love To The Birthday Girl

$6.00

Pale pink and blue birthday card with stripe liner

May All Your Wishes Come True

$6.50

Pale pink and gold foil star magical birthday card

Magical Happy Birthday

$6.00

Gold foil congratulations card with grey envelope and dot liner

A Toast To You

$6.50

Black and white polka dot birthday card with pink envelope

Polka Dot Birthday

$6.00

Dusty rose birthday card with white foil "Birthday Love To You"

Birthday Love

$6.00

White greeting card with gold foil paired with pink envelope with gold heart liner

Bundle of Love

$6.50

Cream and black card printed with Mr and Mrs with a brushed leopard dot liner

Playful Mr. and Mrs.

$6.50

White and blue birthday card with "Forever Young"

Forever Young

$6.50

My Heart Misses You friendship card printed in neon pink with gold heart liner

My Heart Misses You

$6.50

1 2 Next
×

Let's be penpals

Sign up to receive 20% off your first order.*

*Exclusions may apply.

Thank you!

Your discount code is: WELCOME20

  • Bestsellers
  • Greeting Cards
  • Personalized Gifts
  • Custom Stationery
  • Planners
  • Our Story
  • Wholesale
  • Our Stores
  • Curbside Pickup
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Shipping + Returns
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Gift Cards
  • Catalog Sign Up

Sign up to receive 20% off your first order.

Exclusions may apply.

© 2021 Sugar Paper — Site by Aeolidia
Something went wrong, please contact us!
Continue shopping View cart

May we suggest...

Felt Pen, Pale Pink
Felt Pen, Pale Pink $4.00 Liquid error: product form must be given a product
Subtotal:
View cart